Is this an easy A?
MissionImpossible
16/100Students repeatedly say almost no one earns an A, hard work still lands Cs or lower, and new .
Both online and As; online adds zero-for-AI claims.
The decision
Key questions
Is this an easy A?
Students repeatedly say almost no one earns an A, hard work still lands Cs or lower, and new x x x x x.
Both online and x x x x x As; online adds zero-for-AI claims.
Is the course easy?
Content is college writing with x x x x, and standards above typical freshman level.
In-person and x x x x x and multi-essay semesters.
Is attendance flexible?
Most reviews mark attendance mandatory, with x x and strict classroom rules.
In-person is clearly mandatory; x x x x x x x x x sections.
Is this professor recommended?
Low take-again rate and a flood of x x x x x x x x fans.
Negativity dominates both formats; x x x x x x.
Course guide
Grading
Harsh
14/100
x x x x x x x x x, and grades often kept off Canvas.
Format shift
Online reviews stress AI zeros; x x x x x and public call-outs.
Workload
Heavy
24/100
x x x x x x, and writing-center dependence keep the load high.
Format shift
Online async still piles essays; x x x and participation.
Teaching experience
Poor
32/100
Passionate teaching for a minority, but x x x x x x x.
Format shift
Older in-person fans praise growth; recent reviews across formats are largely negative.
Assessment method
FocusOnAssignments
28/100
Grade hinges on few major essays plus homework, with limited transparent interim grades.
Format shift
Same paper-first pattern online and in person.
Luni fit check
Weigh these signals against your actual schedule.
Get help balancing workload, grading, and timing when no option is an obvious fit.
Course format
Classroom format
High confidence · Best fit for Hardcore Learner
x x x x x x x x, public grade call-outs, and mass drops; most report no As and harsh essay grading.
Main concern
Strict classroom rules, AI accusations, and x x x x x x.
What students said
“No one in the class gets a A. x x x x and so unreasonable. x x x!!”
“Her class went from 45 to 12 students within two weeks and I just dropped today.”
“Mrs. Evans was seriously a phenomenal professor. She helped me improve my writing in ways I didn't even think possible.”
Remote format
Medium confidence · Best fit for Self Taught Pro
Online WR1 is still essay-heavy with harsh zeros, AI accusations, and x x; a few organized students who email drafts early do better.
Main concern
Zeros and plagiarism claims on original work with x x x.
What students said
“She claims every thing is AI even if you really wrote it. Give a complete zero I don't recommend taking this Professor waste of time!”
“Definitely a x x x x x x, but I think you'll earn the grade depending on the effort that you put in.”
“Professor Evans was very knowledgeable and caring. I hadn't written an x x x x and her instruction really helped me improve my writing.”
Exam style
Assessment is mostly papers and occasional quizzes rather than student-friendly open exams.
Assessment risk
Standard
42/100
Low score means less forgiving assessment conditions.
In-person adds pop quizzes, seat moves, and x x x x x x.
“She's also started to NOT give PARTIAL credit on any homework assignment, quiz, or essays--ONLY full points OR a 0%”
“3 books, 4 essays, & a x x x”
Online comments emphasize essay zeros and AI plagiarism claims more than proctored finals.
“She claims every thing is AI even if you really wrote it. Give a complete zero”
“accused me of plagiarism. It is as if she wants you to fail”
Student evidence
Top student voice
“If x x x x x x x; it's extremely workload heavy, and she is an x x x. I don't think a single person passed her class. DO NOT TAKE HER.”
“No one in the class gets a A. x x x x and so unreasonable. x x x!!”
“Is very strict with grading, and claims a lot is written by AI or taken from other classmates even if you wrote it yourself.”
“x x x x x x x x x!!”
“Ill tell you how to get an A, literally just set up meetings with her x x x x x x x x x”
Theme 1
Theme 2
Theme 3
Data context
Analysis sample
50
Recent reviews read by the AI
97
Lifetime ratings
88/100
Evidence confidence
50 recent and older reviews across WR1 and ENG200 show consistent tough-grading themes despite some positive outliers.
Inside 50 stored ratings
Reported outcomes
44 reported outcomes
A+ 1 · A 6 · A- 1
B+ 2 · B 3
C+ 2 · C 5 · C- 2
D+ 4 · D 2
F 2
Drop/Withdrawal 6 · Incomplete 2 · Not sure yet 3 · Rather not say 3