AI Rate Professor

Astronomy

Melinda Weil

ASTRON19 · ASTR1 · ASTRO17 · ASTR19 · ASRT1 · AST1 · 149 lifetime ratings

AI rating
28/100
RMP rating
4.0/5
Take again
49.23%
Difficulty
3.1

The decision

Avoid unless , and willing to document every instruction carefully.

Best fit · Hardcore LearnerHarsh gradingConfusing instructionsHeavy discussionsResponsive for some studentsPolarizing online experience
  • Recent online reviews are overwhelmingly , and stressful communication.
  • Positive reviews praise her passion, caring tone, and feedback, but this is .
  • Getting an A appears possible but not easy because , and late policies can sharply affect grades.

Key questions

Four answers before you build your schedule.

Is this an easy A?

HardWork

30/100

Students report that A-level work requires careful compliance with strict instructions, long discussions, quizzes, and .

Online reviews provide most evidence of , while the an easy A.

Is the course easy?

Challenging

34/100

The astronomy content may not be math heavy, but , and dense assignments make the course challenging.

Both online and , though online reviews provide much stronger evidence.

Is attendance flexible?

Varies

45/100

, but , and late-work policies are described as strict.

Online reviews describe strict deadlines and late policies; .

Is this professor recommended?

Avoid

32/100

The dominant recent tone warns students away because , and policies feel harsh or unclear.

Online reviews drive the , while and also mostly negative.

Course guide

See how this professor fits your week.

Grading

Harsh

15/100

Many students say she deducts heavily for , and discussion details.

Format shift

Online reviews overwhelmingly support harsh grading, and .

Workload

Heavy

28/100

Students repeatedly , and exam preparation as time-consuming.

Format shift

Online reviews give the clearest workload pattern, while .

Teaching experience

Poor

38/100

Some students find her caring and knowledgeable, but recent reviews repeatedly describe , , and condescending communication.

Format shift

Online reviews are highly polarized but trend negative recently; and mostly negative.

Assessment method

Balanced

62/100

Grades appear , and assignments rather than one single method.

Format shift

Online reviews give most assessment detail; , and assignments.

Luni fit check

Weigh these signals against your actual schedule.

Get help balancing workload, grading, and timing when no option is an obvious fit.

Course format

Compare the in-person and online experience.

Classroom format

In person

6 reviews

Medium confidence · Best fit for Hardcore Learner

In-person evidence is limited but mostly negative, with complaints about workload, textbook dependence, and .

Main concern

The and strict grading.

What students said

“the . this class was unbareable”
ASTR19
“it's so draining.”
ASTR1
“ .”
ASTR1

Remote format

Online

44 reviews

High confidence · Best fit for Hardcore Learner

Online reviews dominate the record and show a highly polarizing class, with many recent students , and stressful policies.

Main concern

and harder than a general education science course should be.

What students said

“shes an extremely unfair grader and .”
ASTR19
“ ”
ASTRO17
“She is a wonderful teacher navigating teaching difficult material.”
ASTR19

Exam style

Know what to expect from exams and major assignments.

because reviews mention important midterms and , and severe penalties for leaving an exam page.

Midterm And FinalWeekly QuizzesBrowser Exit PenaltyNo Extra CreditTwo Quiz Attempts Mentioned

Assessment risk

Strict

32/100

Low score means less forgiving assessment conditions.

In person

and assignments, but do not clearly prove proctoring, webcam use, Lockdown Browser use, open-book policy, or .

QuizzesAssignments
“ with whats on the assignment/quizzes.”
ASRT1
“ .”
ASTRO17

Online

Online reviews explicitly mention weekly quizzes, major midterm and in some versions, and failing the exam if leaving the browser.

Weekly QuizzesMidterm And FinalBrowser Exit PenaltyNo Extra CreditTwo Quiz Attempts Mentioned
“The real challenge is the midterm and the final.”
ASTR1
“You can't exit the browser when you have a ”
ASTR19
“ ”
AST1

Student evidence

See what students actually said.

Top student voice

“Coming from an A student, this GE req. class does not need to be this hard.”

Voice snapshots generated from 50 reviews, highlighting key themes in , and teaching tone; credibility rating: High.

⚖️

15/100

“will grade down on typo or grammar error.”

🎯 Teaching Quality

38/100

“She is a wonderful teacher navigating teaching difficult material.”

⚠️ Course Risk

32/100

“taking this class genuinely took years off my life.”

Theme 1

⚖️

  • She is a .
  • will grade down on typo or grammar error.
  • She'll say “great job” and .

Theme 2

📚 About Workload & Structure

  • 20-question quiz and a discussion weekly.
  • .

Theme 3

👨‍🏫 About Teaching Style

  • She is a wonderful teacher navigating teaching difficult material.
  • .
  • Professor Weil cares about her students and loves teaching Astronomy.

Data context

See exactly what the AI read.

Analysis sample

50

Recent reviews read by the AI

149

Lifetime ratings

92/100

Evidence confidence

Credibility is high because 50 reviews include many recent detailed comments, though the review tone is polarized.

Inside 50 stored ratings

Quality ratings

5 out of 5105
4 out of 59
3 out of 55
2 out of 56
1 out of 525

Course coverage

ASTR118 reviews
ASTR1913 reviews
ASRT19 reviews
ASTRO176 reviews
AST13 reviews
Show 1 more courses
ASTRON191 review

Reported outcomes

B range results lead the reported letter grades.

38 reported outcomes

A range

11

A+ 1 · A 10

B range

15

B+ 6 · B 8 · B- 1

C range

4

C 4

D range

0

No reported values

F

0

No reported values

No letter grade reported

8

Drop/Withdrawal 1 · Incomplete 1 · Not sure yet 3 · Rather not say 3