AI Rate Professor

Music

Carol Menke

MUSP17A · MUSC17A · MUSCP17A · MUS3 · MUS17A · MUSIC17 · MUS3A · BEGINNINGVOICE · MUS17 · MUS5189 · MUSIC17A · 21 lifetime ratings

AI rating
64/100
RMP rating
3.8/5
Take again
50%
Difficulty
3.4

The decision

if you want real vocal growth and ; skip if you want a gentle beginner class.

Best fit · Hardcore LearnerHarsh but effectiveBest voice teacherDemanding feedbackIntimidating critiquesPractice required
  • Exceptional singer and technique coach who pushes students hard.
  • Harsh public critiques polarize beginners and thin-skinned students.
  • and daily practice are expected.

Key questions

Four answers before you build your schedule.

Is this an easy A?

HardWork

38/100

As and Bs appear, but harsh critiques, practice expectations, and public singing mean an A requires real effort.

; no online reviews.

Is the course easy?

Challenging

36/100

, and solo singing make the content harder than a casual voice elective.

; no online reviews.

Is attendance flexible?

Mandatory

22/100

and stress showing up and practicing.

; no online reviews.

Is this professor recommended?

Depends

55/100

Strong praise from serious singers balanced by harshness and unfair-grade complaints; .

; no online reviews.

Course guide

See how this professor fits your week.

Grading

Strict

38/100

Tough critiques and occasional unfair-grade claims outweigh the .

Format shift

.

Workload

Moderate

48/100

Regular practice and class singing are required, but it is not described as .

Format shift

.

Teaching experience

Good

72/100

Many call her the and credit major skill gains despite intimidation.

Format shift

.

Assessment method

FocusOnAssignments

35/100

Assessment centers on in-class singing, technique feedback, and a .

Format shift

.

Luni fit check

Weigh these signals against your actual schedule.

Get help balancing workload, grading, and timing when no option is an obvious fit.

Course format

Compare the in-person and online experience.

Classroom format

In person

21 reviews

High confidence · Best fit for Hardcore Learner

In-person voice and musicianship classes with public singing, harsh critiques, and strong skill gains for willing students.

Main concern

Harsh critiques and .

What students said

“Carol is the (and it is not even close, unfortunately), and you will become a better singer if you are willing to trust her plan.”
MUS17A
“We would only go over the songs once in class, then we were expected to get up in front of everyone and sing it w/no music, while she gives harsh critiques.”
MUS17A
“She can seem to be harsh or rude at times, but if you speak to her about whatever was said; and provide help.”
MUSCP17A

Remote format

Online

0 reviews

Low confidence

No stored summary is available for this format.

Main concern

No main concern is stored for this format.

Exam style

Know what to expect from exams and major assignments.

Students sing in front of peers with blunt critiques and face a .

In-class solo singingHarsh critiquesRecital final

Assessment risk

Standard

48/100

Low score means less forgiving assessment conditions.

In person

Public singing, harsh critiques, and a .

In-class solo singingHarsh critiquesRecital final
“you do have a ... a recital but if you love singing this is awesome”
MUS17A
“we were expected to get up in front of everyone and sing it w/no music, while she gives harsh critiques”
MUS17A

Online

Student evidence

See what students actually said.

Top student voice

“Carol is the (and it is not even close, unfortunately), and you will become a better singer if you are willing to trust her plan.”

Voice snapshots generated from 21 in-person reviews, highlighting teaching skill, harsh critiques, and performance pressure. Credibility rating: High.

🎯 Teaching Quality

72/100

“She is the best music teacher ever. She always so helpful and .”

⚡

38/100

“For a beginning class of singers, most of which have no experience at all, she is way to harsh.”

📈 Skill Growth

78/100

“I wasn't even sure I could sing before taking this class. Now I'm convinced almost anyone can sing if they work hard enough and have a great teacher like carol.”

Theme 1

👨‍🏫 About Teaching Style

  • She is .
  • She tells it like it is. She is very straight forward, yes. And NO she is not tactful.
  • She can seem intimidating, though she really cares.

Theme 2

📈 About Difficulty & Grades

  • Don't be a slacker! You get as much out of the class as you put into it.
  • I barely scraped an A-.
  • She gave me a very unfair grade.

Theme 3

🎤 About Performance Pressure

  • Everyone who was horrified of singing in front of crowds were confident because of her!
  • I lost any confidence I had in myself.
  • you do have a ... a recital

Data context

See exactly what the AI read.

Analysis sample

21

Recent reviews read by the AI

21

Lifetime ratings

82/100

Evidence confidence

21 detailed in-person reviews spanning many years with consistent themes on harshness and teaching quality.

Inside 21 stored ratings

Quality ratings

5 out of 511
4 out of 55
3 out of 51
2 out of 51
1 out of 53

Course coverage

MUS17A8 reviews
MUSCP17A3 reviews
MUS3A2 reviews
BEGINNINGVOICE1 review
MUS171 review
Show 6 more courses
MUS31 review
MUS51891 review
MUSC17A1 review
MUSIC171 review
MUSIC17A1 review
MUSP17A1 review

Reported outcomes

A range results lead the reported letter grades.

5 reported outcomes

A range

2

A 2

B range

1

B 1

C range

1

C 1

D range

0

No reported values

F

0

No reported values

No letter grade reported

1

Not sure yet 1