AI Rate Professor

Physics

Shel Randall

PHY105 · PHYAPH0A · INTROPHYS · PHYS1 · PHYS10 · PHYS0 · PHYS110 · PHYS310 · PHYS2A · PHYS0000 · PHYS0A · PHYSICS10 · PHYS105 · PHYSA · 81 lifetime ratings

AI rating
41/100
RMP rating
3.1/5
Take again
41.67%
Difficulty
3.3

The decision

Only take if and ; skip if you need clear lectures or an easy physics path.

Best fit · Effort For RewardUnique homework gradingTake-home examsLots of homeworkPolarizing lecturesFunny but tough
  • and is graded in a strict pick-two or format-specific way many call unfair.
  • Supporters love his humor, demos, and ; critics say lectures confuse and force self-teaching.
  • Online COVID reviews are especially harsh about course packs and teaching yourself.

Key questions

Four answers before you build your schedule.

Is this an easy A?

FairEffort

52/100

An A is reachable if you master his homework format and put in hours, but .

In-person students report workable As with effort; online COVID reviews describe much harder paths.

Is the course easy?

Challenging

34/100

Physics content plus unorthodox homework and light intro.

Both formats call material hard; .

Is attendance flexible?

Recommended

62/100

, but problem-solving sessions and participation help if you use them.

Evidence is mostly in-person; .

Is this professor recommended?

Depends

42/100

About two in ; love-him or hate-him split on teaching style and .

In-person is polarized; both online reviews say no.

Course guide

See how this professor fits your week.

Grading

Strict

32/100

Tough grader tags dominate; rigid method even when answers are right.

Format shift

In-person complaints about format and ; .

Workload

Heavy

24/100

called the bulk of the course.

Format shift

; online packs add reading load.

Teaching experience

Average

48/100

Charismatic and funny for some, scatterbrained and hard to learn from for others, with .

Format shift

In-person highly split; online COVID reviews are strongly negative on teaching.

Assessment method

FocusOnAssignments

28/100

and occasional quiz or game-show final.

Format shift

Consistent homework weight online and in person; .

Luni fit check

Weigh these signals against your actual schedule.

Get help balancing workload, grading, and timing when no option is an obvious fit.

Course format

Compare the in-person and online experience.

Classroom format

In person

48 reviews

High confidence · Best fit for Hardcore Learner

In-person experience splits between fun, memorable lectures with take-home exams and , and heavy weekly work.

Main concern

rigid format, so one miss can tank the grade.

What students said

“The bulk of your grade in this class is homework, and ”
PHYS105
“lectures are a waste of time (he just reads off his Powerpoints), and the homework system is unfair (assigns 15-20 problems, then only looks at 2 of them)”
PHYS110
“ home exams, final is a game show, no stress, fun labs”
PHY105

Remote format

Online

2 reviews

Low confidence · Best fit for Self Taught Pro

COVID online physics forced heavy self-study from course packs with and little lecture help.

Main concern

Condescending tone and expectation to learn .

What students said

“If you are taking online (COVID) be prepared to teach yourself. He only lectures if you ask questions.”
PHYS105
“Almost 70% of the and he grades HARD. Just because a problem isn't done his way, its wrong.”
PHYS105

Exam style

Know what to expect from exams and major assignments.

, so exam pressure is lower than the .

Take-home examsOpen multi-day examsGame-show style finalHomework majority of grade

Assessment risk

StudentFriendly

74/100

Low score means less forgiving assessment conditions.

In person

Multiple , and a game-show style final.

Take-home testsExams open multiple daysGame-based final
“ though.”
PHYS110
“ and 4 hours long”
PHYS105
“ , no stress”
PHY105

Online

and and self-teaching instead.

Homework-dominated grade
“Only passed because .”
PHYS105

Student evidence

See what students actually said.

Top student voice

“The all the homework and he grades two problems at random, instead of an overall assessment of how well you understand topics, it is a gamble on whether your grade is tanked.”

Voice snapshots generated from 50 reviews (2 online, 48 in , and exam format. Credibility rating: High.

📝

24/100

“assigns 15-20 problems, then only looks at 2 of them”

🎭 Polarized Teaching

48/100

“Shel is a charismatic, extremely funny, and passionate guy.”

🏠

74/100

“ though.”

👎 Recommendation Split

42/100

“ if you are going to need to get into more series of physics classes.. ”

Theme 1

👨‍🏫 About Teaching Style

  • His lectures are fun and memorable
  • and is very full of himself
  • lectures are a waste of time (he just reads off his Powerpoints)

Theme 2

📈 About Difficulty and Grades

  • homework are usually 15 problems and still would grade only 2
  • If you use every resource at your disposal, you will struggle to fail
  • Just because a problem isn't done his way, its wrong

Theme 3

⚠️ About Classroom Vibe

  • I felt uncomfortable in every class with the inappropriate jokes
  • rude and horrible professor
  • and will make sure you pass his class, as long as you put in effort

Data context

See exactly what the AI read.

Analysis sample

50

Recent reviews read by the AI

81

Lifetime ratings

86/100

Evidence confidence

50 detailed reviews over many years with and polarized teaching, so patterns are reliable despite opinion split.

Inside 50 stored ratings

Quality ratings

5 out of 525
4 out of 517
3 out of 512
2 out of 57
1 out of 520

Course coverage

PHYS1013 reviews
PHYS10512 reviews
PHYS1107 reviews
PHY1055 reviews
PHYS12 reviews
Show 10 more courses
PHYSA2 reviews
1051 review
INTROPHYS1 review
PHYAPH0A1 review
PHYS01 review
PHYS00001 review
PHYS0A1 review
PHYS2A1 review
PHYS3101 review
PHYSICS101 review

Reported outcomes

A range results lead the reported letter grades.

30 reported outcomes

A range

18

A+ 1 · A 16 · A- 1

B range

9

B+ 2 · B 7

C range

0

No reported values

D range

0

No reported values

F

0

No reported values

No letter grade reported

3

Drop/Withdrawal 2 · Not sure yet 1