Is this an easy A?
MissionImpossible
12/100Grades cluster in Ds and Fs; even careful work is nitpicked and AI accusations are common.
; in-person has far more grade failure stories.
The decision
Key questions
Is this an easy A?
Grades cluster in Ds and Fs; even careful work is nitpicked and AI accusations are common.
x x x x x x; in-person has far more grade failure stories.
Is the course easy?
Heavy reading, frequent responses, and x x x x x x x x x advanced.
Difficulty is high in person; online also called very hard.
Is attendance flexible?
Attendance is usually required and x x x x x x x x.
Most evidence is in person; both x x x x x x.
Is this professor recommended?
Take-again rate near 10% with a flood of x x x x x.
Online and in-person both warn away; rare x x x x x x.
Course guide
Grading
Harsh
12/100
Students report severe nitpicking, low scores on responses, and frequent AI-related grade hits.
Format shift
x x x x x; online also labels him a x x.
Workload
Heavy
28/100
Constant reading responses, essays, quizzes, and rewrites create a heavy writing load.
Format shift
x x x x and quizzes; online notes hard grading on limited work.
Teaching experience
Awful
18/100
Recent consensus is rude, demeaning, and unhelpful despite a few older claims of writing growth.
Format shift
In-person carries most evidence; online experiences were also strongly negative.
Assessment method
FocusOnAssignments
30/100
x x x x x x, and in-class writing more than traditional exams.
Format shift
Both formats stress essays and responses; x x x x and x x.
Luni fit check
Weigh these signals against your actual schedule.
Get help balancing workload, grading, and timing when no option is an obvious fit.
Course format
Classroom format
High confidence · Best fit for Hardcore Learner
x x x x x x x x, nitpicky grader who accuses students of AI use and kills GPAs.
Main concern
Harsh interpersonal style plus strict essay x x x x x x x.
What students said
“x x if you can. x x x x x x x, and he treats students like we're all beneath him.”
“x x x x!!!! he says everyone of this students uses AI even from his past students”
“x x x. Grades with the weirdest side comments that make no sense.”
Remote format
Low confidence · Best fit for Hardcore Learner
Both online reviews report tough grading, his-way-or-highway expectations, and poor outcomes including an F and a withdrawal.
Main concern
Hard class with x x and little enjoyment online.
What students said
“it is a very hard class I don't like the class I was at a C but went down to an F”
“He very much likes things to be done his way or the highway. Good luck as he is a x x!”
Exam style
x x x x x x and quizzes with little student-friendly cushion.
Assessment risk
Strict
28/100
Low score means less forgiving assessment conditions.
x x and finals are often in-class essays with picky standards and reading quizzes.
“x x x and x x x x x.”
“Midterm and finals were in-class essays.”
Online comments only x x x x x x x.
“Good luck as he is a x x!”
Student evidence
Top student voice
“x x if you can. x x x x x x x, and he treats students like we're all beneath him.”
“Literally the x x x x”
“He really don't care about our writing, he believes that we don't know anything at all, and he thinks our work was from AI”
“x x x x x x x x x x!!!”
“Jerry Sider made me hate writing. He's overly strict, nitpicks every word”
Theme 1
Theme 2
Theme 3
Data context
Analysis sample
50
Recent reviews read by the AI
57
Lifetime ratings
88/100
Evidence confidence
50 reviews with a large recent negative cluster, detailed grade outcomes, and consistent tough-grader language create high confidence in the x x.
Inside 50 stored ratings
Reported outcomes
35 reported outcomes
A+ 1 · A 5
B 1 · B- 1
C+ 2 · C 3 · C- 2
D+ 1 · D 2 · D- 1
F 7
Drop/Withdrawal 5 · Incomplete 2 · Not sure yet 1 · Not_Sure_Yet 1