AI Rate Professor

English

Jay Rubin

ENG1A5 · ENGL1A · ENG1A · ENGL5 · ENG5 · 1A · ENG · 171 lifetime ratings

AI rating
39/100
RMP rating
3.5/5
Take again
44.09%
Difficulty
3.6

The decision

if you want a demanding writing class and can follow exact formatting rules without needing much flexibility.

Best fit · Hardcore LearnerHarsh formatting rulesHeavy writing workloadDetailed feedbackPolarizing personalityDirection-dependent grading
  • Students consistently say success depends on following his directions exactly.
  • , and little tolerance for mistakes.
  • Some students value the structure and feedback, but negative experiences are intense and frequent.

Key questions

Four answers before you build your schedule.

Is this an easy A?

HardWork

42/100

An A is possible if you follow directions exactly, but strict formatting, frequent writing, and harsh deductions make it high-effort.

Online and , though online reviews provide more examples of rule-based success.

Is the course easy?

Challenging

35/100

The content is not conceptually impossible, but the course feels challenging because instructions, formatting, and writing volume are demanding.

Online reviews emphasize weekly essays and rigid instructions, while and scaffolding.

Is attendance flexible?

Mandatory

25/100

Reviews mention mandatory weekly discussions, strict deadlines, no late work, and little room for error.

Online evidence clearly points to strict participation and deadlines, while .

Is this professor recommended?

Avoid

38/100

Recommendations are split, but the strongest pattern is that many students warn against him because of and rigid rules.

Online reviews are very polarized with many severe warnings, while and also split.

Course guide

See how this professor fits your week.

Grading

Strict

25/100

Students repeatedly describe harsh grading, formatting deductions, and little tolerance for small mistakes.

Format shift

Both formats mention strict grading, with online reviews giving the most detailed examples.

Workload

Heavy

25/100

The workload is writing-heavy, , and detailed formatting requirements.

Format shift

Online reviews strongly emphasize weekly papers and workload, while as time-consuming.

Teaching experience

Poor

48/100

and structure, but many describe him as rigid, condescending, or unsupportive.

Format shift

Online evidence is highly polarized, while and severe criticism.

Assessment method

FocusOnAssignments

15/100

, and written assignments rather than exams.

Format shift

Both formats focus on papers and written work, with .

Luni fit check

Weigh these signals against your actual schedule.

Get help balancing workload, grading, and timing when no option is an obvious fit.

Course format

Compare the in-person and online experience.

Classroom format

In person

7 reviews

Medium confidence · Best fit for Effort For Reward

In-person reviews are also polarized, with some students praising scaffolding and learning while others .

Main concern

Strict grading and .

What students said

“He grades his stuff hella strict.”
ENG5
“I learned so much about the mechanics of writing and thinking.”
ENG5
“Save yourself and select a different professor.”
1A

Remote format

Online

43 reviews

High confidence · Best fit for Hardcore Learner

Online reviews describe a demanding writing course with strict formatting rules, frequent papers, and and fairness.

Main concern

and rigid directions.

What students said

“Just follow the directions, CAREFULLY, and you'll get an A.”
1A
“You have to write 1-2 essays per WEEK, yes per week.”
ENG5
“He is very tough on formatting, but once you get that handled the class is pretty much smooth sailing.”
1A

Exam style

Know what to expect from exams and major assignments.

Reviews do not clearly prove a consistent exam policy, and assessment appears .

Reviews Do Not Clearly Prove Exam PolicyWriting-Based AssessmentWeekly Essays

Assessment risk

Standard

55/100

Low score means less forgiving assessment conditions.

In person

, open-book, midterm, or final exam policy.

Reviews Do Not Clearly Prove Exam PolicyWriting And Formatting Focus
“Summarizing, exact formatting and brevity are a big part of the class.”
ENG5

Online

Online reviews do not clearly prove webcam, proctoring, open-book, midterm, or .

Reviews Do Not Clearly Prove Exam PolicyWeekly EssaysDiscussions
“About 1 essay every week or two”
ENG5
“weekly essays and discussions”
ENG5

Student evidence

See what students actually said.

Top student voice

“Just follow the directions, CAREFULLY, and you'll get an A.”

Voice snapshots generated from 50 reviews, highlighting key themes in , and polarized teaching experience. Credibility rating: High.

⚖️

25/100

“Even if you put an extra space on your paper you'll be docked by a lot of points.”

📚 Workload

25/100

“You have to write 1-2 essays per WEEK, yes per week.”

🎯 Teaching Quality

48/100

“ .”

Theme 1

📝 About Directions

  • Follow directions, and if needed
  • Follow the instructions LITERALLY.
  • Thinks critical thinking is only about following his absurd rules.

Theme 2

⚖️

  • He grades hard, but if you follow the instructions, everything is good.
  • .
  • He took off a lot of .

Theme 3

📚 About Workload

  • The workload is demanding, with weekly essays and discussions

Data context

See exactly what the AI read.

Analysis sample

50

Recent reviews read by the AI

171

Lifetime ratings

92/100

Evidence confidence

Credibility is high because 50 reviews include recent, detailed, and , and strict directions.

Inside 50 stored ratings

Quality ratings

5 out of 574
4 out of 541
3 out of 514
2 out of 53
1 out of 540

Course coverage

1A15 reviews
ENG513 reviews
ENG1A8 reviews
ENGL1A5 reviews
ENG3 reviews
Show 2 more courses
ENG1A53 reviews
ENGL53 reviews

Reported outcomes

A range results lead the reported letter grades.

46 reported outcomes

A range

17

A+ 1 · A 14 · A- 2

B range

9

B+ 3 · B 5 · B- 1

C range

5

C+ 3 · C 1 · C- 1

D range

1

D- 1

F

0

No reported values

No letter grade reported

14

Audit/No Grade 1 · Drop/Withdrawal 4 · Not sure yet 6 · Rather not say 3