AI Rate Professor

Physics

YI Xie

PHY1 · PHYS11L · PHYLB1 · PHYLB001 · ASTRON01 · ASTRO001 · PHYSI11 · MATH262 · ASTRON001 · 16 lifetime ratings

AI rating
29/100
RMP rating
2.5/5
Take again
14.29%
Difficulty
3.2

The decision

Avoid YI Xie unless you can teach yourself, tolerate unclear lectures, and .

Best fit · Self Taught ProUnclear LecturesHeavy HomeworkHard TestsLimited SupportMixed Lab Experience
  • Many students say .
  • , and as heavy or frustrating.
  • Some lab and older reviews praise her as nice and helpful, but the dominant tone is negative.

Key questions

Four answers before you build your schedule.

Is this an easy A?

HardWork

32/100

An A may be possible in some labs, but most comments , and unclear teaching that raise the effort cost.

The lone online review suggests unsupported homework, while hard astronomy exams.

Is the course easy?

Challenging

30/100

The course feels difficult because students report , and large amounts of information.

Online evidence points to self-teaching, while , and heavy workload.

Is attendance flexible?

Varies

45/100

Reviews do not clearly state an .

Neither online nor .

Is this professor recommended?

Avoid

24/100

Most students do not recommend her because teaching is often described as , and test-heavy.

The online review is negative, and positive lab comments.

Course guide

See how this professor fits your week.

Grading

Strict

35/100

Some lab credit appears forgiving, but astronomy and , and low grades.

Format shift

, while in-person reviews conflict between forgiving labs and .

Workload

Heavy

22/100

Workload is heavy because students repeatedly mention lots of , and book work.

Format shift

The online review mentions homework without lectures, while and long labs.

Teaching experience

Poor

28/100

Teaching quality is low overall because many students describe unclear lectures, poor communication, little support, and self-teaching.

Format shift

Online evidence is weak due to one review but negative, while and mostly critical.

Assessment method

Balanced

62/100

Assessment , and finals rather than relying on only one method.

Format shift

Online evidence mentions homework, while , and .

Luni fit check

Weigh these signals against your actual schedule.

Get help balancing workload, grading, and timing when no option is an obvious fit.

Course format

Compare the in-person and online experience.

Classroom format

In person

15 reviews

High confidence · Best fit for Self Taught Pro

but mostly critical, citing unclear lectures, lots of , and poor communication.

Main concern

The main concern is and .

What students said

“NEVER TAUGHT US A SINGLE THING LOL!”
ASTRON001
“Didnt teach, just threw book work at us.”
PHYSI11
“her midterms were hard even w/the 1 page cheat sheet”
ASTRO001

Remote format

Online

1 reviews

Low confidence · Best fit for Self Taught Pro

The single online review says she posted homework without her own lectures or .

Main concern

Online support appears weak because the review says there were no instructor-made lectures.

What students said

“she just gives us homework without providing any lectures of her own”
PHYSI11

Exam style

Know what to expect from exams and major assignments.

because and midterms, though reviews do not clearly prove proctoring or closed-book rules.

Hard MidtermsOne Page Cheat SheetTest HeavyPolicy Not Fully Clear

Assessment risk

Strict

32/100

Low score means less forgiving assessment conditions.

In person

and midterms, including one page of notes, but do not clearly prove proctoring or closed-book rules.

Hard MidtermsOne Page Cheat SheetTest Heavy
“her midterms were hard even w/the 1 page cheat sheet”
ASTRO001
“It just consists of boring lectures and tests.”
ASTRON01
“Test heavy”
PHYSI11

Online

The online review does not clearly prove exam format, proctoring, webcam use, Lockdown Browser, or open-book policy.

No Clear Exam Evidence

Student evidence

See what students actually said.

Top student voice

“Didnt teach, just threw book work at us.”

Voice snapshots generated from 16 reviews, highlighting key themes in , and support. Credibility rating: High.

🎯 Teaching Quality

28/100

“I couldn't understand her most of the time and it didn't help that she spoke very fast while writing illegible equations on the board.”

📚 Workload Pressure

22/100

“ !!!! TONS OF HW.”

👍 Recommendation Rate

24/100

“I would really .”

Theme 1

👨‍🏫 About Teaching Style

  • Didnt teach, just threw book work at us.
  • NEVER TAUGHT US A SINGLE THING LOL!
  • I couldn't understand her lectures. all she did was talk and write on the chalkboard.

Theme 2

📈 About Difficulty & Grades

  • her midterms were hard even w/the 1 page cheat sheet
  • because of the amount of information she would give at once
  • The but she gave you credit for attempting to do them.

Theme 3

⚠️ About Support & Communication

  • She gets an F rating for the simple reason that she doesn't answer any emails
  • she just gives us homework without providing any lectures of her own
  • , and the lab.

Data context

See exactly what the AI read.

Analysis sample

16

Recent reviews read by the AI

16

Lifetime ratings

84/100

Evidence confidence

Credibility is high because 16 reviews span many years and show a consistent pattern of and heavy .

Inside 16 stored ratings

Quality ratings

5 out of 52
4 out of 54
3 out of 50
2 out of 55
1 out of 55

Course coverage

ASTRO0013 reviews
ASTRON013 reviews
PHYSI113 reviews
ASTRON0012 reviews
MATH2621 review
Show 4 more courses
PHY11 review
PHYLB0011 review
PHYLB11 review
PHYS11L1 review

Reported outcomes

No letter grade reported results lead the reported letter grades.

5 reported outcomes

A range

1

A+ 1

B range

0

No reported values

C range

0

No reported values

D range

0

No reported values

F

0

No reported values

No letter grade reported

4

Incomplete 1 · Not sure yet 3